III. Learning To Be a "Real Chalet School Girl"


The importance of being a "real Chalet School girl" - fitting into the community by following the moral code of the school - is a recurring theme in the series. For example, in Jo Returns to the Chalet School (1936), Jo tells her headmistress: "I'll never be anything else, Mdlle. Even when I'm an old lady with white hair, telling all my great-great nieces and nephews [at this point she is still determined not to marry] all about my wicked deeds, I'll never count myself as anything but a Chalet School girl." (Brent-Dyer, 1936, pp17-18). Later in the series, when she is married and a mother, Jo repeats: "I'm still, in part of me, what I shall always be - a Chalet School girl" (Brent-Dyer, 1950a, p192). In Tom Tackles the Chalet School (1955) (first published in 1947 in The First Chalet School Book for Girls), Jem Russell's niece Daisy proclaims at the end of the book that Tom Gay, who had originally been brought up as a boy, "is really a Chalet School girl at last!" (Brent-Dyer, 1955a, p83).
mor1

To readers familiar with the series the characteristics of a "real Chalet School girl" would have been easily recognisable, as the moral and spiritual values the school espoused were made explicit in the texts. In this the series mirrored real schools for middle-class girls, about which Evans has written:

mor2

Although individual books do not encompass all Brent-Dyer's moral teachings, a reading of the series as a whole identifies a number of recurring themes. Perhaps the character trait held up by the books as being the one most desirable is 'to think of others', although this trait does not necessarily include self-sacrifice. Brent-Dyer introduces this theme in the series in relation to pupils behaving charitably towards those less fortunate than themselves, in particular towards the inhabitants of the villages surrounding the school. This is first mentioned in the fourth book of the series, The Head Girl of the Chalet School (1928), when the girls hold their first sale of work to sponsor a free bed at the sanatorium for local children (Brent-Dyer, 1928, pp218-219). The Robin, then aged six, sets an example by saving her pocket money to put towards the costs of the bed. The theme continues in the following book, The Rivals of the Chalet School (1929), when the girls discuss how hard the winter is for many of the local people - "one of the aims of the Chalet School was to teach them to think of others" (Brent-Dyer, 1929, p15).
mor3

Brent-Dyer treated the theme more prominently in the following book, extending it to include a girl's family and friends as well as those less fortunate than the pupils. Eustacia Benson is sent to school because she has thought of no-one but herself, and thus "has upset the whole house" (Brent-Dyer, 1930, p9). Later in the same book the headmistress tells her that she is responsible for the other girls ignoring her because she has not considered them (Brent-Dyer, 1930, p57). However, despite the fact that Eustacia spends most of the book in conflict with the rest of the school, Jo is reprimanded by both Madge and a mistress, Miss Stewart, for not seeing Eustacia's point of view (Brent-Dyer, 1930, pp88, 147), underlining the lesson that everyone both deserves consideration and in turn must be considerate towards others.
mor4

Acting charitably towards local people continues to be a theme throughout the Tirolean books (Books 1-13; 1925-1938). For example, in The Exploits of the Chalet Girls (1933) the prefects discuss the hardships that the peasants face in winter with deep concern (Brent-Dyer, 1933, p17). And in Jo Returns to the Chalet School (1936) the girls are asked by the headmistress to extend their charity to a poor parish at Innsbruck, especially by making children's clothes to give away at Christmas. When Jo later sells her first manuscript she sends the cheque to the parish (Brent-Dyer, 1936, pp10, 152-154). At the very end of the book Jo tells the priest, Vater Stefan, who is attending their Christmas play: "isn't it fair that we should share all we can with those who have so little? . . . we are taught to do so" (Brent-Dyer, 1936, p162). Once the school has relocated in the British Isles the girls continue to support the sanatorium, but the beneficiaries of their charity are now British, and this remains the case when the school returns to the Alps. "They were all very anxious to do everything they could for the big Sanatorium; and whatever they made went to supporting free beds for British children who need the clean Alpine air and rich milk" (Brent-Dyer, 1955c, p117). There is no obvious explanation for this change in focus, as Brent-Dyer remained committed to internationalism throughout the series.
mor5

The theme of thinking about the needs of friends and family members recurs throughout the series, with varying focuses. In The Chalet School and the Lintons (1934) Joyce Linton is shocked to discover how ill her mother is because she has only thought of her own needs (Brent-Dyer, 1934, pp18, 24). As Joyce is very fond of her mother, this episode shows that being selfish can blind someone to information which they would rather have, possibly with serious consequences. In the same book Gillian Linton, Joyce's elder sister, is told by Jo that she should not keep taking responsibility for Joyce, partly because "it's not fair on you", and that she has helped to spoil Joyce (Brent-Dyer, 1934, pp34, 110). This episode stresses that there are limits to the extent to which it is desirable to put someone else's needs first, for the sakes of both parties involved. A girl should think of others as well as herself, not necessarily before herself.
mor6

However, the books also stress that some degree of self-sacrifice is sometimes necessary for a Chalet School girl. In Jo Returns to the Chalet School (1936), Jo is persuaded to join the staff until the end of the term to allow a mistress, Miss Stewart, time to convalesce properly, although she dislikes teaching (Brent-Dyer, 1936, pp108-109). This type of behaviour is shown to be desirable later in the book, when she wins a prize for being the "most helpful" at a half-term "sheets and pillowcases" party (Brent-Dyer, 1936, p129). Perhaps not surprisingly, self-sacrifice continues to be portrayed as desirable during the war years. In Lavender Laughs at the Chalet School (1943) Bride Bettany agrees to swap her cubicle with Lavender's so that Lavender can comfort Lilamani, whose mother has died - Bride has a window cubicle, considered to be the best in the dormitory (Brent-Dyer, 1943, p165). Later in the same book Lavender cancels her preferred holiday to go away with Lilamani, both for Lilamani's sake and for the sake of the seniors who have invited Lilamani to stay (Brent-Dyer, 1943, pp168-170). These episodes portray quite ordinary actions, well within the reach of both the fictional pupils and the series' readers.
mor7

Significantly, the greatest degree of self-sacrifice is needed when girls mature and become young women. For example, in The Chalet School and the Island (1950) sixth-former Dickie Christy is described as spending her weekends helping at home with younger members of the family. Later, in Shocks for the Chalet School (1952), Elfie Woodward gives up school to look after her family, following the death of her step-mother. Bride Bettany, her best friend, "knew, almost better than anyone else, just what a sacrifice the girl was making . . . Bride realised dimly that Elfie, being what she was, could have done nothing else" (Brent-Dyer, 1952b, p24). By the beginning of Bride Leads the Chalet School (1953) it is Bride's sister Peggy who is prepared to give up her last two terms at the finishing branch to look after their mother, who is recovering from a serious operation (Brent-Dyer, 1953a, pp10-11).
mor8

However, Peggy is saved from this because her aunt offers to come to stay with Peggy's mother, and Elfie too returns to school when a relative assumes responsibility for her family. Dickie's family recover their fortune, and her mother is then able to afford help in the house. There is no need for the girls to continue to be self-sacrificing when circumstances change. Self-sacrifice may on occasions be necessary, but it is never suggested that girls should sacrifice themselves because their lives are not as important as their male relatives, nor that they gain in strength of character as a result. Instead, self-sacrifice results from the strength of character that the girls already have. For example, the school secretary Rosalie Dene, herself an old girl, tells Bride: "Elfie, being what she is [my emphasis], would never have been happy if she had done as she wants and come back" (Brent-Dyer, 1952b, p27).
mor9

The emphasis that Brent-Dyer placed on thinking of others in the series is perhaps best illustrated by Jo's founding of the Margot Venables prize in Gay from China at the Chalet School (1944), "to go to the girl, who, in the estimation of the School, has done most to help other people" (Brent-Dyer, 1944, p170). As has already been discussed, Jo is seen to embody all the most desirable qualities of a Chalet School girl, and her choice of criteria for the prizewinner would be seen to illustrate this. It is probable that thinking of others would have been a common theme in middle-class girls' schools at the time, and indeed Evans has memories of a similar prize to Joey's at her own school.

mor10

A related character trait that Brent-Dyer emphasises as desirable in the series is forgiveness. For example, in Bride Leads the Chalet School (1953) Bride tells Miss Annersley that she will not be happy unless she forgives Diana Skelton, who has wrecked Bride's study out of spite. "The Head nodded. 'Of course you couldn't be happy!' she said. 'Otherwise, Nancy, what becomes of "Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive them that trespass against us?'" (Brent-Dyer, 1953a, p236). In the following book Miss Annersley tells Bride: "'Let him that is without sin among you cast the first stone'. Have you forgotten that? . . . Later, as you grow older, I hope you will learn that there are generally extenuating circumstances if we try to look for them." (Brent-Dyer, 1953b, pp32-33). This is also related to Brent-Dyer's use of the pastoral convention common in classic children's fiction of viewing all characters as essentially good or at least as capable of change.
mor11

The importance of being polite and having good manners is also emphasised in the series, and this seems to be related to the emphasis that is placed on the importance of thinking of others. For example:

In a later book Miss Annersley talks about: "acts of courtesy that here are considered necessities . . . politeness is the rule" (Brent-Dyer, 1953a, pp90-91). These include punctuality: "Punctuality was a virtue on which much stress was laid at the Chalet School" (Brent-Dyer, 1941, p118).
mor12

Good manners extend to eating habits too. For example, in The Exploits of the Chalet Girls (1933) Cornelia Flower and Evadne Lannis are punished for playing a kicking game under the dinner table. Miss Wilson tells them: "All bad manners are disgusting; but bad table manners are, perhaps, the worst". The girls accept this at face value and are "very subdued" (Brent-Dyer, 1933, p122). Greed is also seen as very undesirable. For example, in The Chalet School and the Lintons (1934) Miss Annersley tells girls who have held a midnight feast which has resulted in two of the girls involved being ill that she was "bitterly ashamed to think that Chalet girls could be so greedy" (Brent-Dyer, 1934, p83). Later, in The New Chalet School (1938) Jem Russell treats girls who have made themselves ill through eating fruit by concocting:

It is possible that Brent-Dyer's treatment of greed is related to twentieth-century constructs of femininity that portray thinness as extremely desirable for girls and women. However, on many occasions Brent-Dyer describes large meals composed largely of sweet food as very desirable and good to eat, so it is more likely that she associates this trait with self-control and self-discipline.
mor13

When girls are rude, it is treated very seriously. For example, in The Exploits of the Chalet Girls (1933) Thekla loses her temper, calls one of the prefects a "Schweinhund" and spits at her, disgusting the prefects and staff (Brent-Dyer, 1933, p34). In a later book, The Chalet School and the Island (1950), Annis Lovell is rude to a member of staff and is kept in solitude and silence until she agrees to apologise; her peers have no sympathy for her (Brent-Dyer, 1950a, pp34-37).
mor14

However, Brent-Dyer makes some distinction in the books between good manners, which are extremely desirable, and social graces masquerading as good manners, which are not so important. For example, in The Chalet School in Exile (1940) Janie Lucy, Jo's new neighbour, intends to make a "proper twenty-minutes' call" to Jo, but stays for much longer. She teases her that they must later make calls with cards, but this is not treated as a serious possibility (Brent-Dyer, 1940, p192). In a later book Bride Bettany, Jo's niece and a role model, criticises Diana Skelton because she "goes in for 'elegant' manners. I've seen her cocking her little finger in the air when she holds her cup myself! She went on nibbling daintily and sipping at her tea like someone's maiden great aunt" (Brent-Dyer, 1953a, pp155-156). Perhaps it is significant these references do not occur until after the outbreak of war, when British society was undergoing one of its greatest upheavals.
mor15

Perhaps one of the reasons that thinking of others and forgiving the problems they may cause you is perceived as desirable in the series is the fact that, as has already been discussed, the series is about a community rather than an individual. In order to fit into this community new members must learn to put the community's needs before their own, and to be tolerant of others. 'Fitting in' is portrayed as essential in all the texts. For example, in Bride Leads the Chalet School (1953) Jo advises Bride:

Bride later explains to Diana:

mor16

In a later book, Ruey Richardson, Chaletian (1960), Ruey, Jo's ward, begins her first term "wondering how she was really going to like having her actions hedged in, as she quite saw they must be, at a boarding school" (Brent-Dyer, 1960b, p8). But by the end of the book Joey tells her: "You've become a real Chaletian - someone who can face the hard things of life as well as accepting the pleasant ones. Someone who's going to be some good to the world and her fellow human beings" (Brent-Dyer, 1960b, p157). Part of the way Ruey has achieved this is by learning to fit in and accept the rule of the majority.
mor17

The qualities that are portrayed as most necessary for community integration are self-discipline and obedience. It is the lack of these qualities which inevitably threatens the status quo and hurts either the person without such qualities or someone close. For example, in The Head Girl of the Chalet School (1928) Grizel, the new Head Girl, runs off to see the Schauffhausen Falls on the way back to school, despite the fact that she has been forbidden to do so. As a result she is threatened with the loss of her position (Brent-Dyer, 1928, pp72-76). Later, in Eustacia Goes To The Chalet School (1930), Eustacia's lack of self-discipline leads to a mistress hurting her foot and the school party spending a night on a mountain as a result, which also indirectly causes the Robin to become ill. Another mistress tells Eustacia: "If only you had learned self-control, all this need never have happened" (Brent-Dyer, 1930, p121).
mor18

Perhaps the most extreme example which Brent-Dyer gives of the dangers of lack of self-discipline and obedience is in The New Chalet School (1938), where two children who are not pupils of the school, the Balbini twins, run wild and refuse to obey orders while their mother is in the sanatorium. As a result they miss their mother's last call for them, and she dies without saying goodbye. Jem Russell tells them that: "Your foolish behaviour has brought its own punishment. Your mother asked for you repeatedly before she died, and she had to go with her last wish for you ungratified" (Brent-Dyer, 1938, p284). As the death of a parent is a deeply traumatic occurence in reality and one which threatens fundamentally a child's security, it is probable that Brent-Dyer chose this example because she believed strongly that self-discipline and obedience were very important. However, Brent-Dyer also stresses the positive advantages of obedience. For example, in The Chalet Girls in Camp (1932), the girls escape from a swarm of hornets by being "promptly obedient" (Brent-Dyer, 1932, p92).
mor19

Another quality that is advocated in the series is patience, seen to be closely related to self-discipline. For example, in Peggy of the Chalet School (1950) Jo says: "I've learnt to wait for my good things. It's a hard lesson, but if we learn it properly, it does help to make life easier for us" (Brent-Dyer, 1950b, p87). Later, in Carola Storms the Chalet School (1951), Jo tells Grizel: "when things go wrong, it's just as well to learn to hold your horses a little" (Brent-Dyer, 1951a, p158). In the latter example Grizel's impatience has led to an accident in which Carola and Jo's eldest triplet Len have been burnt, an extreme example of the consequences of lacking self-discipline .
mor20

Perhaps not surprisingly, a character trait that is portrayed as antagonistic to community life and therefore undesirable is the desire for privacy. In Three Go To The Chalet School (1949) Mary-Lou resists becoming a boarder because she will not have any privacy, and this is dismissed by both her grandmother and Jo (Brent-Dyer, 1949, pp358, 363). Later, in The Chalet School Does It Again (1955), the girls laugh over a new girl who has said "'that one so frequently wants a little privacy'. . . 'Cripes!' gasped Emerence. 'She must be crackers!' They all agreed with this. Whoever had heard of a girl of fourteen demanding privacy!" (Brent-Dyer, 1955b, p10).
mor21

Physical violence is another trait that is portrayed as undesirable, although interestingly this is never described as an unfeminine characteristic. Rather physical violence is seen as childish, and resulting from a lack of self-discipline. For example, in Lavender Laughs at the Chalet School (1943) Lavender hits a girl who has insulted her aunt.

In a later book, The Chalet School and the Island (1950), a fight breaks out in the Lower Third: "The entire form was embroiled in a free-for-all" (Brent-Dyer, 1950a, p59). Their punishment includes a dictat that "for the rest of the term they were to be treated like the Kindergarten" (Brent-Dyer, 1950a, p63).
mor22

However, Brent-Dyer also stresses the positive aspects of belonging to a community, particularly in her treatment of friendship between girls. This is portrayed as of such value that girls should risk their lives if necessary to protect a friend. For example, in Three Go To The Chalet School (1949), Mary-Lou's mother tells her that dying to save a friend "is the sort of thing real friendship means" (Brent-Dyer, 1949, p413). In fact it is Mary-Lou's father who has done this, but there is no suggestion that this is a quality confined to men. Later in the same book Jo talks to Mary-Lou about friendship, stressing the need for tolerance of other people's habits - another quality necessary for community integration.

mor23

Brent-Dyer also emphasises the symbiotic nature of friendship. One example of this is the character of Mary Woodley in The Chalet School and Barbara (1954):

Once established, however, friendship is seen as enduring, rather than ephemeral, and something that should be taken on trust. For example, in Changes for the Chalet School (1953), Jo tells a group of girls who are being split up by the school's move to Switzerland:

(McClelland points out that in contrast Brent-Dyer herself frequently lost interest "in friendships that had apparently been close" [McClelland, 1981, p95].)
mor24

While Brent-Dyer places great emphasis in the series on the duties and advantages of belonging to a community, she is also careful to stress the need for self-reliance within it. As well as thinking of others, it is important to think for oneself. For example, in Carola Storms the Chalet School (1951), Carola is told by headmistress Miss Annersley: "If you stay here, you must learn to think" (Carola has run away from her cousin without realising that she would be very worried) (Brent-Dyer, 1951a, p56). Carola's lack of forethought is a recurring theme in the book, which ends with the line: "Carola made her usual excuse. 'I - I didn't think!'" (Brent-Dyer, 1951a, p159). In this instance she has been badly burned as a result of beating out a fire with her bare hands instead of using a nearby table cloth, so the message is a serious one: lack of forethought can harm oneself as well as others.
mor25

In another example Brent-Dyer shows that individuals can protect themselves by being self-reliant, and indeed have a duty to do so. In The Wrong Chalet School Blossom Willoughby is tricked into going to an artroom before an important tennis match, and is consequently locked in and prevented from playing. However, if she had thought before she acted she would have seen through the trick and would never have gone to the artroom in the first place. Although the girl responsible is caught and punished, Blossom "had not been spared in the study, for it had been pointed out to her very plainly that her own lack of thought had been largely to blame for her unpleasant experience" (Brent-Dyer, 1952a, p130). Although people's feelings are always treated seriously in the series, Brent-Dyer always insists that emotion must be tempered by thought, and that thought and self-discipline must ultimately govern emotion, to portray her ideal of rational womanhood.
mor26

Self-reliance is also shown to be important in relationships. For example, in The Chalet School in the Oberland (1952) a rift opens between two girls after one had allowed the other to dominate her.

mor27

Evans, writing about her own experience of a middle-class girls' school in the 1950s, has noted that:

mor28

The emphasis that real middle-class girls' schools placed on communal values has also been noted by Evans, who has concluded that at her middle-class girls' school:

mor29

Thinking of others; tolerating their idiosyncracies and forgiving them when necessary; fitting into a community; being obedient, patient, well-mannered and self-disciplined; abiding by the wishes of the majority; setting a good example to younger children; and giving up the right to privacy; are of course also lessons which encourage girls to fit into traditional family roles, although this is never portrayed explicitly in the texts.
mor30

However, the emphasis which Brent-Dyer placed on the importance of women's friendships and communal life would have been more controversial. Following the publication of Radclyffe Hall's The Well of Loneliness in 1928 women's relationships with other women came under suspicion and attack, and Vera Brittain was just one feminist writer who felt the need to defend such relationships, albeit by pointing out that relationships need not intefere with a women's role as lover, wife and mother.

mor31

In addition to communal values, the series emphasises other qualities that are found in a 'real Chalet School girl', as well as some which are not. One of the most important of the former is a 'sense of honour', which includes being honest and trustworthy. For example, in The Chalet School and the Lintons (1934) Jo tells girls who are disobeying the rules by passing notes in class: "Here, we have always considered it utterly dishonourable" (Brent-Dyer, 1934, p64). In the following book, The New House at the Chalet School (1935), Miss Wilson assures Matron that the perpetrators of a joke will own up if asked because none of them are "cowardly or dishonourable" (Brent-Dyer, 1935, p82). Later, in Tom Tackles the Chalet School (1955): "There was no talking. They knew Clare had put them on their honour, and the Chalet School was strict about honour" (Brent-Dyer, 1955a, p88). Significantly, only two girls are expelled during the series, Thekla, who has "no sense of honour" (Brent-Dyer, 1934, p65), and Betty, who had previously been caught eavesdropping - "something thoroughly dishonourable" (Brent-Dyer, 1942, p84).
mor32

Another quality shown to be important is belief in the Christian god. Brent-Dyer was known to be a practising Christian for most of her life, initially within the Anglican church and later within the Catholic, and her beliefs are prominent within the books. For example, in The Chalet School in Exile (1940) the girls lament that there is nothing that they can do to help Maria Marani's father, who is being held by the Nazis. The Robin says:

mor33

On another occasion Julie Lucy, a prefect, is dangerously ill with peritonitis. Miss Annersley tells her sister Betsy: "The biggest thing you can do for Julie at the moment is to pray for her" (Brent-Dyer, 1953a, p132). Faith in the Christian god's powers is as important as prayer itself. For example, in The Wrong Chalet School (1952) Katherine Gordon has faith that her parents, who are being held by the Chinese government, will be released unharmed (Brent-Dyer, 1952a, p8). When this happens she says: "I knew God would look after them and He did - He did!" Miss Annersley replies: "He always does if we could only learn to trust Him" (Brent-Dyer, 1952a, p79).
mor34

However, being religious in the series consists of more than simply praying and having faith; it is seen as an integral part of the characters of girls held up as role models. For example, in The Chalet School and Jo (1931) Jo becomes so absorbed in the Oberammergau Passion Play that "her eyes were glowing with a deep, inward glow as of one who sees a vision" (Brent-Dyer, 1931, p108). (It is believed that Brent-Dyer wrote this book after paying her own visit to Oberammergau in 1930 [McClelland, 1981, p123].) Much later in the series Peggy Bettany, Jo's eldest niece, talks to the other girls about her favourite saints (as has previously been discussed, Brent-Dyer converted to Catholicism, and seems to have forgotten that it would have been very unusual for Peggy, a Protestant, to display an interest that would have been considered heretical by her own church).

Significantly, Mary-Lou, another role model, is also religious:

mor35

Wilson has noted that the post-war period was characterised by a revival in religious belief and a movement away from science (Wilson, 1980, pp128-129), and it is possible that these later examples reflected that. Traditional constructions of femininity which have portrayed men as rational and scientific and women as emotional and instinctive also seem relevant to Brent-Dyer's portrayal of religious belief, based as it is on faith and emotional response rather than on proven scientific fact.
mor36

Another quality which is valued in the series is courage, both mental and physical, and it is perhaps not surprising that this quality is most frequently referred to during the books written and published in wartime. Mental courage is first mentioned in Jo Returns to the Chalet School (1936), when Matron decrees that the older girls must be told that Mademoiselle, their headmistress, is dangerously ill. "I don't believe in trying to shield girls from all sorrow and trouble. We want to make strong, helpful women of them - not spineless jellyfish!" (Brent-Dyer, 1936, p139). Later a former pupil, Bette Rincini, who is now a refugee in Canada is held up as an example of this ideal by Joey: "She's plucky, Corney. First she lost Giovanni [her husband]; then she lost her home; and now she's lost every penny of her money, and has to start work" (Brent-Dyer, 1940, p288).
mor37

Physical courage is first mentioned in the same book, The Chalet School in Exile (1940) when Madge Russell tells the school:

Later in the same book Cornelia, the recipient of both Madge's speech and of Jo's, rescues two Germans from a burning plane, getting badly burned in the process. "For a moment Cornelia drew back, and no-one can blame her. Then she set her teeth. The Chalet School mustn't have a coward in it . . . With an inarticulate prayer for courage, Cornelia leapt" (Brent-Dyer, 1940, pp296-297). (It is typical of Brent-Dyer's belief in internationalism and peace that Cornelia rescues two Germans rather than two Allied servicemen, as one might expect to be the case in a popular children's story during wartime.) Examples of physical courage still occur, though more rarely, after the war years. For example, in Tom Tackles the Chalet School (1955) Daisy Venables, Jem's niece, carries a friend through a snowstorm to safety despite hurting her shoulder badly (Brent-Dyer, 1955a, pp66-73).
mor38

It is interesting that death or its possibility is constantly present in the series, most often portrayed in connection with the sanatorium but also in connection with the need for physical and mental courage. It is possible that this reflected Brent-Dyer's religious beliefs, as well as her childhood experiences of bereavement. This is also endorsed by the differing memories of Mary Evans, who attended a girls' school where the pupils were almost exclusively Anglican, and Sarah Hogg, who was head girl in her final year at her girls' boarding school run by nuns. Evans remembers death being treated by her school as "the kind of raw emotion that had been ruled out of order since our childhoods" (Evans, 1991, p46). In contrast Hogg remembers her school as "a community that had the whole of life right through, including death, to deal with" (Bennett and Forgan, 1991, p113).
mor39

Unsurprisingly, given the stress the series lays on 'being brave', 'real Chalet School girls' are not expected to be easily scared, and if they are scared, they are not expected to show it. For example, in The School at the Chalet (1925) Amy Stevens, one of the youngest pupils, crys when she sees a snake when the school is out for a ramble. Madge, the headmistress, tells her: "There's nothing to cry about, Amy . . . If you scream when you only see a snake, you aren't a very plucky person, are you? Now dry your eyes and stop crying." (Brent-Dyer, 1925, p114). Later in the same book Simone is the victim of Madge's disapproval when she becomes hysterical after the school is caught in a storm.

mor40

In a later book, The New House at the Chalet School (1935) Matron Besly, a very unpopular character, becomes hysterical during a storm, and Miss Wilson, later to be one of the headmistresses, is "disgusted" (Brent-Dyer, 1935, p117). Girls are also not expected to complain. In Three Go To The Chalet School (1949) Jo tells Mary-Lou: "You've got to take the rough with the smooth like everyone else, and whining won't get you anywhere" (Brent-Dyer, 1949, pp360-361). And in a later book "Matron noted thankfully that there seemed to be only one whiner in the school, at any rate" (Brent-Dyer, 1952c, p145).
mor41

Another characteristic that is shown to be undesirable is pride, which is shown to be most harmful to the girl exhibiting it. For example, in Eustacia Goes to the Chalet School (1930):

Instead Eustacia runs away and as a result is badly injured. This theme is repeated in The Chalet School and the Island (1950), when Annis Lovell would like to change her mind about running away. "But if she did that, then she must make up her mind to remain a kind of pensioner on Aunt Margaret's grudging bounty, and that was more than her pride would allow" (Brent-Dyer, 1950a, p156). As a result she narrowly escapes death by drowning. Not all examples are so extreme, although all show that pride is harmful. In Three Go To The Chalet School (1949):

mor42

A related quality, vanity, can also lead to harm. In The Chalet School in the Oberland (1952) Elma is disgraced because she has been corresponding with a man her parents had forbidden her to contact. She tells Peggy Bettany that she was not in love with him after all.

This man continues to cause Elma problems until Miss Wilson deals with him (Brent-Dyer, 1952c, pp172-173).
mor43

"Vulgarity" is another characteristic that is frowned upon in the series (The Concise Oxford Dictionary [1976] defines "vulgar" as "Of or characteristic of the common people, plebeian, coarse in manners, low"). For example, in The Chalet Girls in Camp (1932) Jo suggests to Juliet Carrick, an old girl, that she has forgotten to bring the cocoa to camp because she was so busy thinking about her fiance. "Juliet turned on her coldly. 'That is not funny, Jo. It is even verging on the vulgar. If you must be funny, at least try to avoid vulgarity, please!' Jo flushed." (Brent-Dyer, 1932, p48). In The New Chalet School (1938) Madge's husband Jem Russell tells Maria Balbini, whose mother is dying in the sanatorium: "there's not need to be ill-bred, no matter how angry you are. Vulgarity won't help you, you know." (Brent-Dyer, 1938, p243). Vulgarity is also mentioned during the war years, when the Middles get into trouble for wearing "Weezes" on their heads during a gardening lesson. A prefect later reports that:

mor44

However, despite the above examples, snobbery is also frowned upon in the series. This is first made explicit in the first book of the series, The School at the Chalet (1925), when it seems likely that there will be two new girls coming to the school.

The Von Eschenaus do attend the school, and later their cousin Thekla is astonished to find that they "consort with daughters of shopkeepers". Jo's friend Frieda Von Ahlen replies: "What difference can it make if we ourselves are good and kind and gentle?" (Brent-Dyer, 1933, p27). Later Frieda expands on this: "We never trouble about what our fathers are. The thing we think of is what we ourselves are . . . Drop all these foolish ideas, and become one of us" (Brent-Dyer, 1933, p42). Belonging to the community and being a 'real Chalet School girl' is what is important, not family background.
mor45

The belief that snobbery is an unacceptable trait continues to be repeated throughout the series (eg Brent-Dyer, 1953a, pp77-78,101,145). One book in particular, A Problem for the Chalet School (1956) places the theme that it "is what we ourselves are" that matters at the centre of the plot. Rosamund Lilley, who has a scholarship, is concerned that "they'll all be looking down their noses at me because we live in a little house and Dad's a market gardener and Mum was a housemaid" (Brent-Dyer, 1956c, p5). This continues to concern her until Joey, whose eldest triplet Len is Rosamund's friend, reassures her:

mor46

Given Brent-Dyer's strong religious beliefs and the fact that she herself came from a modest family background and needed to work to support herself throughout her adult life, it is probable that these passages are close to her own feelings. However, pupils attending real middle-class girls' schools during the time in which Brent-Dyer was writing remember very different experiences. For example, journalist and novelist Frances Donnelly remembers that at her Ursuline convent in the 1950s and 1960s:

Liz Heron recalls that at her Catholic girls' school in the late 1950s:

Ursula Huws, who like Rosamund was sent to boarding school at someone else's expense, had a very different experience to Rosamund's fictional one.

The implications of the largely middle-class background of the Chalet School pupils is discussed further in 6: V.
mor47


Next: 6: IV. Adolescence and Sexuality
Return to: 6. The World of the Chalet School Index
Return to: Virtual Worlds of Girls Index

Dr Ju Gosling aka ju90's ABNORMAL: How Britain became body dysphoric and the key to a cure is available now for just 3.09 for the Kindle or in a limited-edition hardback with full-colour art plates for 20 inc UK postage and packing. Book cover